I also use "Secure and Accessible PHP Contact Form v.2.0WP" on several sites. Its easy to configure, and seems robust to the point of being bullet-proof.
(
www.green-beast.com/blog/?page_id=136)
Pros:Users like the "Carbon Copy" option
The anti-spam filter is simple but effective
Works with multiple versions of Wordpress
Cons:No option to add custom fields... that would be good :-)