Hi Sarah
Well, interesting...
1.) the robots.txt file is correct, although you should also have your Google XML Sitemap plugin installed, and the sitemap referenced in the robots.txt file!
2.) Looking at View Source on home page, there are no iterations of Noindex/Nofollow, so that's not the problem either.
Your reference to "Google Webmaster account" leads me to conclude that you've probably told Google that your site is "
www.SarahTaylor.com" and that they should index that Domain / URL... Following your instructions, they go there, BUT... it does not exist!
Unfortunately for you, your site is actually set up as "SarahTaylor.com" - WITHOUT the WWW!!!
- change the General Settings on the site to use the WWW. For anyone else reading this, you really should consistently use WWW on EVERY reference to your site, to prevent issues such as this (and others) arising!
Regardless of what you might think, "SarahTaylor.com" and "
www.SarahTaylor.com are two completely different things as far as the SE's are concerned.
All In One SEO is not your problem... But you do need Google XML sitemaps installed, and you do need to fix your Permalinks so they generate Search Engine Friendly-URL's!
At that point, things will work a whole lot better for you, down at Google HQ!